The Italian star now boasts eight of his 12 career matches against the German player.
World number two Jannik Sinner secured his seventh straight win over his German rival to qualify for the Miami Open final for a fourth occasion.
The Italian triumphed 6-3 7-6 (7-4) and will meet Czech Jiri Lehecka in the weekend's title decider.
The reigning Wimbledon champion is looking to secure a second Miami crown in three years and emerge as the first man since Roger Federer in 2017 to pull off the prestigious 'Sunshine Double', following his recent win in Indian Wells just weeks ago.
Sinner, a four-time major champion, who also beat world number four Zverev in the California semi-finals two weeks prior, continued his incredible form.
"This has been an fantastic stretch of tournaments," said the Italian, who claimed his sixteenth consecutive win in ATP Masters 1000 tournaments and extended his streak of straight sets won to an impressive 32.
"My goal has been to play as many matches as possible and I couldn't do any better.
"Today was a extremely difficult battle. He played some brilliant tennis, but I was serving exceptionally well, particularly in the final stages and in the key moments.
"Being here again, in the championship match, signifies very, very much to me."
Lehecka Secures Maiden Major Final Spot
In the other semi-final, Lehecka, beat Frenchman Arthur Fils in straight sets, 6-2, 6-2 in an hour and 15 minutes to advance to his maiden Masters 1,000 final.
"I'm very excited that I'm in a championship match," remarked Lehecka.
"However, it's only a sport. There are more important things going on in the world right now.
"My focus is simply to do what I do best."